1952 Dunhill Patent Billiard“So what makes Dunhill pipes so great, anyway? Are they really worth what they cost?”
It seems like an innocent enough question, doesn’t it? Yet, every time this question - or its first or second cousin – shows up in one of the myriad pipe-smoking forums, all hell breaks loose. Sure, sometimes the thread remains restrained or civil, but all too often the thread tone crosses the canyon. Discussion turns to debate and when that happens it is almost certain that there will be a lot more heat than light.
Almost certainly, old-timers roll their eyes and ask themselves, “Do we have to go through this all over again?” I’m sympathetic, I admit, but asking this question is about as reasonable as a Vermonter muttering about mud season coming around again. It’s going to happen and, if you’re around, you’re going to go through it.
Some people – and I’ve been one of them – try to address the question in earnest. The inevitable comparisons between brands and grades of other pipes are made. People who own Dunhills will pronounce their favorite Kaywoodie a superior smoker. Someone who smokes a comparably priced artisan-grade pipe, e.g. a Rad Davis or John Crosby pipe, will make the inevitable argument for putting the money into a truly handmade pipe. Charatan and Savinelli owners will decisively argue for their own preferences. And those who are well-mannered and gracious will almost always close with a statement to the effect of “Of course, this is just my opinion. Smoke what you enjoy and enjoy what you smoke. It’s what’s important to you that matters.”
Click to read more ...